House Hunting

Not sure if I should really call this house hunting since we aren't technically looking very seriously.... We know we want to move within the next couple years and it took us 7 months to find our current place and we were looking at houses almost every weekend of that time. Now that we know the area, the schools, the roads, this house hunt is defined in a way the last one wasn't. Also, we've learned a few lessons with this house (some hard, some funny) and so we have a list of things our next house absolutely must have, and a list of what would be awesome. It's evolving over time, but to give you an idea here is what it currently looks like:

Must Have	Would Like to Have
4 bedrooms, 3 ½ bathrooms	5 bedrooms, 3 full baths, 2 half baths
2 car garage	3 car garage
mudroom off garage entrance	back deck off back to yard
1st open floor plan: eat-in kitchen, breakfast area, large family room	butler’s pantry between kitchen and formal dining room
separate formal dining and office	formal dining, formal living and office
separate laundry room	1st floor laundry room
heating and cooling systems	Geo-thermal and solar
walk-out daylight basement w/high ceilings	finished basement
walk-up attic space	finished attic space
good sized yard - mostly level	private yard - ie end of a cul-de-sac or rd
room to expand - either within the house or add on if needed.	mature trees/ landscaping
wood burning fireplace(s)
hardwood first floor, tile in baths	heated tile in baths
double sink in master bath, sep shower/tub

Here are some pictures of houses we've looked at lately:

Which one do you like best?